Butter For All's Sourdough Master Recipe (2024)

I may receive commission if you purchase through links in this post.

Now that you have your starter in tip-top shape it’s time to play with this one recipe that can do oh-so-many things!

People make sourdough so much more complicated than it needs to be. Sure, you can expand into more detailed and dramatic recipes as your skills progress, but don’t ever forget the humble roots of good bread: flour, water, starter, salt, touch, and time!

This simple recipe will change the way you make sourdough bread. Knowing this one formula will allow you to try different shapes, styles, and flavors with ease.

The Perfect Ratio

This formula is so easy to work with. The dough is the perfect hydration for beginners but more seasoned bakers will also appreciate the flexibility and easy handling. I typically don’t need any additional flour during shaping unless I’m rolling this dough out (like in these delectable market cinnamon rolls).

This recipe was developed for a strong bread flour (one that is high in protein). But if you read on you will see some examples of this formula with multiple whole grain flours.

Tried and Tested

I’ve scaled this formula from one loaf to 25. I get a consistent bake every time with great development and flavor.

Versatile Beyond Comparison

From pizza to pita, this one dough proves itself over and over again!

It even makes a perfect sandwich loaf.

And gorgeous hamburger buns or dinner rolls.

ALL these incredible baked goods were made with the same master recipe.

One recipe that can do it all! What will you try?

Shaping and Baking

The only thing that changes this recipe from one baked good to another is the shaping and baking technique. Mixing the dough, kneading, and the bulk fermentation is standard across the board.

The basic formula makes one 888-gram loaf, or eight 111-gram buns, rolls, or pitas.

Take a minute to watch me shape six totally different styles of baked goods with this one dough!

Watch these other videos for some shaping tips and techniques:

Shaping Boules

Shaping Pitas

Great Bread No Matter the Flour

Not only did I test many different shaping styles with this master recipe, but I also took it one step further and documented the boule process with six flour varieties side by side.

Organic High Mountain High Gluten Flour from Central Milling
Organic Sifted Hard Red Spring Wheat Flour from Camas Country Mill
Organic Whole Wheat Einkorn from Jovial
Organic Dark Rye Flour from Great River Organic Milling
Organic Kamut Flour from Camas Country Mill
Organic Spelt Flour from Food To Live

Mixing Observations

The einkorn needed about 25 grams of additionalwater added at mixing. This gave a pliable dough.

Even though Kamut and rye were also very stiff doughs, I decided to see what would happen without extra water.

This is what the six different doughs looked like after an overnight bulk fermentation at room temperature (68℉) and shaping into boules.

After about 4 hours of proofing, all doughs were nearing double.

Proofing Observations

The einkorn had started to over-proof. It fermented so much faster than the other flours! Perhaps due to that added hydration and the bran to sugar ratio in the flour. It was the first to go in the oven, and while it wasn’t the most aesthetically pleasing loaf, it was delicious! I would bet it would perform better in a loaf pan.

The rye and Kamut dough needed a little more time, probably due to their density and resulting lower hydration. They were baked last.

Here is a side-by-side comparison of how the crumb looked on all six loaves.

Baking and Crumb Observations

The high-gluten flour gave a beautiful lofty loaf with perfect texture and a very mild flavor.
The sifted hard red is my flour of choice — all the flavor of whole grain with a delicate chewy interior. This is the flour I used to develop this master recipe so it will always work out well!
The einkorn had a nice open crumb and a very nice sour tang. You can see the effect of over-proofing in the long gap under the upper crust.
The rye was dense and chewy, perfect for thin slices topped with butter.
The Kamut was also fairly dense but nicely developed with a deep golden color and nutty, buttery flavor.
The spelt had a decent open crumb with good flavor and beautiful color. I thought it baked a little on the dry side though, so it might be a good choice for an enriched whole grain dough or at the least it needs a little more hydration.It may have also over-proofed slightly as you can see a few bubbles right under the crust.

Takeaways

I normally wouldn’t bake boules with 100% whole grain. I often advise people to use 50% bread flour and 50% whole grain. This is especially important if you want to shape your dough into pitas, pizza, or rolls.

However, 100% whole grain loaves can be successful as boules and sandwich loaves.

This was a great test that proved this master recipe’s flexibility. All the bread was delicious and got devoured.

This recipe was developed for finely milled stone-ground hard wheat like the sifted hard red spring wheat from Camas Country Mill. But as I demonstrate above, it can work really well with a variety of white and whole grain flours!

This table provides you with not only the ingredient weight in grams but also in ounces, volume, and baker’s percentages.

Baker’s Percentages

Baker’s percentages are useful for scaling recipes up and down with ease.

Note that the total flour weight is always 100% and every other ingredient is represented as a percentage of the total flour weight. No matter how much flour you use, it is 100% and all the other ingredients are scaled accordingly.

Using the table above, let’s scale a recipe together using baker’s percentages.

I need 30 hamburger buns for a dinner party. I know that the master recipe makes eight 111-gram buns. What do I do?

First, find the total formula weight, the number of buns I need times the weight of one bun: 30 x 111 = 3330

Once we know the total formula weight orthe total flour weight it is easy to find the conversion factor that we will use to scale all the ingredients.

The conversion factor is1% of your flour weight.

To find the conversion factor we take our total weight and divide it by the total formula percentage: 3330 ÷ 195.15 = 17.06 is our conversion factor.

Measuring by Volume

I’ve gotten the volume measurements as close as possible, but please note that they are always approximate. You may need to adjust hydration by adding flour or water to your recipe.

Baker’s percentages also don’t work with volume measurements. So baking by weight has the benefit of being easily scaled in addition to greater accuracy.

Butter For All's Sourdough Master Recipe

Yield: 888 grams (1 loaf, 1 large pizza, or 8 individual servings)

Scaling, Mixing, and Kneading Time: 20 minutes

Cook Time: 35 minutes

Total Fermentation Time: 12 hours

Total Time: 12 hours 55 minutes

Memorize this simple formula and you'll always have a sourdough recipe on hand that can make great bread, pizza, pitas, hamburger buns, cinnamon rolls, and more.

Ingredients

455 grams (3 1/4 cups) organic strong flour
296 grams (1 1/4 cups) water
125 grams (1/2 cup) active starter
12 grams (2 teaspoons) salt

Instructions

In a large bowl or stand mixer, stir all ingredients together to form a shaggy dough.
Alternate kneading and resting the dough in 1-minute intervals until it's smooth and elastic.
Shape the dough into a ball. Place it in a covered bowl to ferment.
Let the dough rise to double in volume, around 8 hours (overnight) in cool room temperature (68°F)
Deflate, portion, and shape the dough as desired.
Cover the dough and let it double again at room temperature.
Bake loaves at 400℉ for 35 minutes or to an internal temperature of 200℉. Pizza and other styles and shapes will require specific baking times and temperatures.
Cool loaves completely before slicing.

Notes

This master recipe can be used with a variety of wheat flours for different styles and shapes of bread or rolls.
Adjust hydration as needed.
Adjust baking times and temperature as needed.
Recipe yields one loaf or eight 111-gram servings.