NY Style Pizza Vs Regular Pizza: Which is Better? — Big Mario's Pizza (2024)

Pizza is one of the world’s most popular meals available today. You would be hard-pressed to find anyone that genuinely dislikes this food. This is because pizza is so versatile. You can top it up with just about any ingredients you like to create a pizza that meets your preferences. However, the toppings on a pizza aren’t the only thing that varies. If you’ve ever had to order a pizza, you’ve probably come across pizzas not just in different sizes but also in different styles. Below, we take a closer look at the New York-style pizza vs regular pizza.

New York Style Pizza Vs Regular Pizza

So what makes New York-style pizza different? Is the New York-style pizza really the best pizza in Seattle? These are arguments that are had almost on a daily basis by pizza lovers. So let’s dive into the different pizza types and what differentiates New York-style pizza from regular pizza.

The crust

This is probably the biggest difference between the two styles. Traditional pizza, also often referred to as Neapolitan pizza, features a large pillow-like crust. The crust is chewy and even throughout. The fire-baked pizza crust features dark charred spots and has a remarkable flavor. The flavor is largely a result of the highly refined wheat flour used to make the dough.

New-York style pies are often easily distinguishable because of their extra-large and thin crust. The crust isn’t as chewy as that in the traditional pie. Because the base isn’t as complex as that of traditional pizzas, it is the perfect backdrop for loading up on layers of toppings and cheese.

How it is eaten

It is fair to say that people have different styles of eating pizza. However, how different pizza styles are enjoyed can distinguish them from each other. The traditional pie was intended to be eaten as a single serving with a fork and knife. It was a meal that people sat down to enjoy.

However, the New York-style pie is different. It was designed to provide a quick and affordable meal to the New York City working class at the time. These people neither had the time or money to enjoy an entire pie.

New York-style crusts are much larger than traditional-style pies. They are designed to be shared. An individual can enjoy a single slice while on the go. The thin crust can be folded to create a sandwich that can be enjoyed without creating a mess. They are the perfect meal for when you’re on the go or for enjoying with family.

The size

As mentioned earlier, the New York-style pizza crust is large. It is in fact significantly larger than the traditional pie. Traditional pies were made to be a single serving for an individual. The average traditional pie measures around 12 inches in diameter.

New York pies were designed to be affordable. Sharing the pizza made it possible for those with limited funds to purchase a slice and enjoy pizza. These pies typically measure about 18 inches.

The cheese

While toppings vary based on the individual’s preferences, there are specific ways these toppings are used on the pie. Traditional styles often feature gobs of mozzarella cheese dotted here and there. Fresh mozzarella is often used. This is a stark contrast to New York styles which feature shredded low-moisture mozzarella.

Fresh mozzarella is often not used on New York-style pizza because these pizzas are cooked for longer than traditional styles. The shredded cheese is also often spread liberally on the pie. This results in that cheesy pie that many people love. However, because the cheese was low in moisture, the pie did not come out soggy. It is still firm and can be folded to minimize messes while consuming it.

The sauce

Another major difference between the styles is the sauces used on the crust. The traditional pie continues to uphold the traditional pizza sauce. This features tomatoes and salt only. The minimal sauce functions as a base on which the flavors of the toppings and the crust can come to life.

The sauces used for New York-style pies on the other hand are distinct for their flavor. They feature chopped garlic, sugar and may also include herbs such as oregano. Some chefs add their own twist to their sauce with other ingredients including red pepper flakes.

Still can’t decide whether the traditional or New York-style pie is better? You should visit Big Mario’s Pizza or order delivery for the best pizza in Seattle. Get a taste of the traditional pie just as it was made in Italy as well as the classic New York Style pizza and make your own decision. You’re sure to keep coming back for more.

NY Style Pizza Vs Regular Pizza: Which is Better? — Big Mario's Pizza (2024)

FAQs

What is the difference between regular pizza and New York Style pizza? ›

New-York style pies are often easily distinguishable because of their extra-large and thin crust. The crust isn't as chewy as that in the traditional pie. Because the base isn't as complex as that of traditional pizzas, it is the perfect backdrop for loading up on layers of toppings and cheese.

Is New York Style pizza worth it? ›

New York-style pizza is renowned for its thin, foldable crust that delivers the perfect combination of chewiness and crispiness. Fans of NY-style pizza argue that its thin crust and quick preparation time make it the ideal choice for a fast and delicious meal. It's perfect for the on-the-go eaters of NY.

What is the difference between a New Yorker pizza and a large pizza? ›

A large pizza from Pizza Hut is 14 inches wide and is cut into 12 slices. The Big New Yorker is 16 inches wide and cut into 6 slices, so you can fold each slice (“just like real New Yorkers do”) and try to convince yourself you're eating just one piece of pizza—not two.

Which type of pizza is more tasty? ›

Margherita is one of the most popular types of Pizza. The toppings contain, basil, fresh mozzarella cheese, a drizzle of olive oil, and fresh tomato sauce. The topping of Margherita pizza may sound simple but they can delight your taste buds. It comes with a thin crust and is cheesy inside.

Why is New York pizza better? ›

New York–style pizza gets its distinguishing crust from the high-gluten bread flour with which it is made. Minerals present in New York City's tap water supply are also credited with giving the dough in metro area pizzas its characteristic texture and flavor.

Is New York-style pizza better than Italian pizza? ›

When it comes to New York and Italian pizza, there is no clear winner. Both styles of pizza have their own unique qualities that make them special. So, the next time you're in the mood for pizza, why not try both and decide for yourself which one is the best?

Why do people love New York pizza? ›

One of the oldest theories about New York City pizza is that the city's tap water is responsible for its superior taste. Many Americans might not know that here in the Big Apple, we're almost as proud of our water as we are of our pizza, and that the city has been adding fluoride to the water for more than 50 years.

What makes NY pizza special? ›

New York-style pizza has slices that are large and wide with a thin crust that is foldable yet crispy. It is traditionally topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, with any extra toppings placed on top of the cheese. Pizza without additional toppings is called “plain,” “regular,” or “cheese.”

Does NY-style pizza have less sauce? ›

NY pizzas generally have a thin layer of pizza sauce that doesn't quite hit the edge of the crust to avoid spilling over. The sauce used on New York-style pizzas is also more heavily seasoned so a little goes a long way to give the perfect crust to sauce ratio.

What is New York style pizza crust like? ›

New York-style pizza dough is an offshoot of Neapolitan-style dough—still a thin crust pie, but slightly thicker than its Italian cousin. The crust is sturdy, but not cracker-like, and instead features a tender chew thanks to the addition of oil in the dough.

Should I get large or XL pizza? ›

Go with the largest size pizza possible: While an extra-large pizza will be more expensive than a medium pizza, the cost per slice is actually less than pizzas of a smaller size.

How big is a large New York style pizza? ›

HUGE slices (yes size does matter in this case-LOL) New York pizza pies are traditionally cooked in sizes of 18” or larger and are offered by the slice, with pies cut into six slices vs. eight those are some pallet pleasing slices that satisfy the most Hangry among us!.

What is the most ordered pizza? ›

This may not come as a surprise, but pepperoni is by far the most popular pizza topping in the United States.

Which pizza type do most people prefer? ›

Most popular crust styles in the United States
  • Thin Crust Pizza. One of the most popular options for many pizza enthusiasts is the thin crust sometimes called a Neapolitan pizza crust. ...
  • New York Style Pizza. ...
  • St. ...
  • Deep Dish Pizza. ...
  • Detroit Style Pizza. ...
  • Marinara Sauce. ...
  • Buffalo Sauce. ...
  • Alfredo Sauce.

Which pizza company is best in taste? ›

However, some popular options in India known for offering good taste at a reasonable price include Domino's Pizza, Pizza Hut, and local pizzerias like Ovenstory Pizza or Mojo Pizza. It's a good idea to check for ongoing deals or discounts to get the best value for your money.

Does NY style pizza have less sauce? ›

NY pizzas generally have a thin layer of pizza sauce that doesn't quite hit the edge of the crust to avoid spilling over. The sauce used on New York-style pizzas is also more heavily seasoned so a little goes a long way to give the perfect crust to sauce ratio.

Is Brooklyn and New York-style pizza the same? ›

What sets it apart from other New York-style pizza?” While there is no hard set of rules or official definition of Brooklyn-style pie, you may notice a pattern in the best pizza places in Brooklyn sets this area apart: The crust is thin and crispy, but also airy. The tomato sauce tends to be less sweet.

How do styles of pizza differ between New York and Chicago? ›

Both offer unique flavors and distinct characteristics. The most noticeable difference between a New York style pizza Versus a Chicago style Pizza is their crust. New your style pizza is known for their thin crust, while the Chicago style pizza is typically thicker and also known deep dish.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5429

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Birthday: 2000-07-07

Address: 5050 Breitenberg Knoll, New Robert, MI 45409

Phone: +2556892639372

Job: Investor Mining Engineer

Hobby: Sketching, Cosplaying, Glassblowing, Genealogy, Crocheting, Archery, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is The Hon. Margery Christiansen, I am a bright, adorable, precious, inexpensive, gorgeous, comfortable, happy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.