The Pros and Cons of Juicing - Center for Psychological Development (2024)

By Sharon Ezop, posted

Health crazes come and go, and some are better than others. You’ve probably noticed over the last couple of years that people seem to really be touting the benefits of juicing. And according to a recent research report, the juicer market is expected to grow by $606.67 million dollars between the years 2019 and 2023.

But what is the truth behind this latest diet fad? Is juicing really that great for you? Does it come with any risks or negative side effects? That’s what this blog post is about to reveal, so keep reading!

The Pros of Juicing

There are different ways that people do a juice fast or cleanse. Some people simply substitute a meal, usually breakfast, with a tall glass of veggie juice. Some people also do short (3-day) and long (30-day) juice fasts. Some people juice their own juices, and some people purchase their juices from a local retailer that juices fresh fruits and veggies.

However you are thinking about incorporating juicing into your life, there are some pros and cons you should be aware of. Here are some of the benefits of juicing:

1. Provides a Lot of Nutrients

Not many of us can actually eat the required seven servings of fruits and veggies a day. But when you push all of that fruit and all of those veggies through a juicer, you can get those nutrients in one tall glass of juice. In other words, juicing is like the superhero of the multivitamin world. Just be sure you are juicing organic fruits and veggies so you aren’t also drinking chemicals.

2. Reduces Produce Waste

How often do you buy produce in an effort to eat healthier, but then just don’t get around to eating it and watch it slowly shrivel in your refrigerator? Well, that limp carrot or cucumber can easily be tossed into your juicer where you can still extract the beneficial nutrients.

3. Hydration

A lot of people drink water all day long hoping to become hydrated. But often that water goes right through them and into the toilet. The chemical structure of vegetable juice mimics that of our own blood plasma, and so this allows the water content to slip through our cell walls, bringing us actual hydration on a cellular level.

The Cons of Juicing

And now let’s look at some of the cons associated with juicing.

1. May Spike Blood Sugar Levels

Even when you juice your own fruits and veggies, you are taking away all of the fiber which counteracts the carb load and you’re left with the juice and the sugar in it. This can cause you to have a major blood sugar spike. For people with insulin resistance or diabetes, these sugar spikes should be avoided.

Additionally, fructose, the sugar in fruits, is processed by the liver. If you drink a lot of fruit juice, this can tax your liver and lead to fatty liver disease.

2. Not Great for Those with Kidney Disorders

Health experts have warned that drinking large quantities of juice may be harmful to those with kidney disorders. Certain fruits and vegetables contain oxalates, an acid that can contribute to kidney stones and other kidney issues.

3. Insufficient Calories

Those who choose to do a juice fast for a number of days or even weeks will most likely experience symptoms such as weakness, fainting, headaches, and hunger from not getting enough calories.

As you can see, juicing comes with its own set of pros and cons, as does every other diet trend out there. While some people with diabetes or kidney issues may want to avoid juicing, other people may very well benefit from drinking a tall glass of vegetable juice every day to get all of the nutrients.

SOURCES:

The Pros and Cons of Juicing - Center for Psychological Development (2024)

FAQs

Is there scientific evidence to support juicing for health? ›

While there are advantages to consuming fruit and vegetable juices, there is no scientific evidence to support the idea that juices and cleanses are a necessity for health. Many health claims presented with juicing and detoxing plans are not based on scientific evidence.

Can juicing help with mental health? ›

Researchers believe that vitamins, minerals, and beneficial plant compounds from different fruits and vegetables — which you get from many types of juice — may offer protective effects on mental health ( 4 ).

What does juicing do for your body? ›

Juicing can play a role in a balanced diet. For instance, it can help you get fruits and vegetables if you don't enjoy eating them. Juicing also can give the digestive system a rest from digesting fiber. This may help some people who have certain health conditions or who receive certain medical treatments.

What is the negative side of juicing? ›

The low calorie content of most juices can elicit fatigue, headaches, cravings and dizziness. It may lead to muscle and bone loss. Because juice contains limited amount of protein, your muscles and bones can be affected.

What are the disadvantages of juicers? ›

Should You Get a Juicer?
  • Pro: Nutrient-Packed Goodness. ...
  • Pro: Easy Digestion. ...
  • Pro: Delicious Variety. ...
  • Pro: Convenient and Time-Saving. ...
  • Con: Costly Investment. ...
  • Con: High Maintenance. ...
  • Con: Fiber Loss. ...
  • Con: Oxidation.
Feb 21, 2024

What do doctors say about juicing? ›

Juicing cuts fiber and can spike sugar

During the cold-pressed juicing process, most of the fiber that's found in pulp is removed. Fiber can help lower cholesterol, promote heart health, and help regulate the body's use of sugar — preventing blood sugar spikes.

Does juicing remove toxins? ›

Juice cleanses also do not remove toxins from your body – your kidneys and liver do the job of detoxification for free. Eat whole fruits and vegetables for the added benefits fiber gives you. Juicing doesn't provide any more benefits than consuming whole fruits and vegetables.

What happens to your body during juicing? ›

Juices, unfortunately, usually strain out any of the beneficial insoluble fiber in fruits and veggies, instead leaving behind a liquid that's high in vitamins and micronutrients but also loaded with natural fruit sugars that have basically the same effect on your body as table sugar.

Which juice is best for depression and anxiety? ›

Research has linked foods like avocado, oranges, or oysters to reduced feelings of anxiety. Drinks like water and 100% fruit juice can also be beneficial if you have a lot of anxiety and stress. Those foods and drinks contain antioxidants, minerals, and vitamins that help alleviate anxiety symptoms.

What is the best juice for the brain? ›

Green Juice

Green juices are packed with vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that support brain health. They are also low in sugar, making them an ideal choice for those watching their sugar intake.

What should you not do while juicing? ›

Are You Making These Common Juicing Mistakes?
  1. You don't consume your juice when it's fresh. ...
  2. Your juice has too much (processed) sugar. ...
  3. It's not cold pressed. ...
  4. You're not hydrating. ...
  5. You're drinking caffeine. ...
  6. You're not eating clean. ...
  7. You're not drinking it on an empty stomach. ...
  8. You're supplementing with the wrong kind of smoothies.

How long does it take to see the benefits of juicing? ›

4-7 Days. If you're looking to achieve some serious weight loss, a longer cleanse is best for you. You won't see any significant results if you cleanse for too short a time. Fruits and vegetables are low in calories and high in nutrients, which is why drinking juice for several days has a weight reducing effect.

What is the healthiest juice to drink? ›

While there are lots to choose from, here are some of the best healthy juices that offer excellent nutritional value.
  • Apple. You are most likely familiar with apple juice and have tried it in different ways, whether fresh or mixed. ...
  • Orange. ...
  • Grape. ...
  • Cranberry. ...
  • Pomegranate. ...
  • Tomato. ...
  • Beet. ...
  • Green Juices.

What vegetables should not be juiced? ›

Vegetables That Should Not Be Juiced Everyday

Spinach contains oxalates and raw kale contains goitrogens. Oxalates are also found in bananas, mangoes, cauliflower, and more. Goitrogens are found in raw cruciferous vegetables and can affect thyroid function in large amounts.

What happens to your body after juicing? ›

"You wake up feeling lighter since your digestive tract isn't as full as when you're eating solid foods," says Dr. Chutkan. You could also have more energy. "Digestion is a very active process and takes lots of resources from the body, such as blood flow and energy to break down food," she explains.

Is juicing bad for your stomach? ›

A while we're on the subject of stomach upset, certain fruits and veggies are so powerful that you may experience some stomach distress if you drink too much of them. Too many leafy greens or wheatgrass can do this. For others, too much beet will do the same.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tyson Zemlak

Last Updated:

Views: 6638

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tyson Zemlak

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Apt. 662 96191 Quigley Dam, Kubview, MA 42013

Phone: +441678032891

Job: Community-Services Orchestrator

Hobby: Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Metalworking, Fashion, Vehicle restoration, Shopping, Photography

Introduction: My name is Tyson Zemlak, I am a excited, light, sparkling, super, open, fair, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.