The Real Reason Soufflé Is So Difficult To Make - Tasting Table (2024)

The Real Reason Soufflé Is So Difficult To Make - Tasting Table (4)

artist11/Shutterstock

ByKaren Greco/

In the final episode of the first season of the HBO Max series "Julia," a fictionalized origin story of Julia Child's public television cooking show, Julia wraps up her first season of "The French Chef" by cooking a chocolate soufflé. The Kitchn points out that in the episode, she makes the soufflé a metaphor for life: Even though something might be intimidating, you just have to jump right in.

As inspiring as that sounds, making a soufflé is indeed intimidating and fussy. MasterClass calls this dish the cooking equivalent of painting a Picasso. The website explains that a soufflé is a baked dish made with eggs that can be made either sweet with fruits and chocolate or savory with cheese and meats. While this sounds simple enough, what you do with the eggs and the precision needed makes the recipe so daunting.

Because soufflés get their impressive poof from egg whites, you must separate those from the yolks with absolutely no cross-contamination. Chef Jeffrey Buben, the owner of the Washington, D.C. restaurant Vidalia, explains to NPR that when you separate the eggs, you are separating fats (yolk) from protein (whites). When the egg whites are whipped, air gets into them; the protein in the whites forms bubbles around that air, which is what keeps the soufflé light and fluffy. If fat is introduced (by a stray bit of yolk, for example), the bubbles don't form properly, causing the dish to fall limp.

Why soufflé is tricky to make

The Real Reason Soufflé Is So Difficult To Make - Tasting Table (5)

MaraZe/Shutterstock

Buben recommends hand-mixing the whites, beginning in a figure eight to break them up before whisking them in a circular motion. It takes about four minutes at 180 beats per minute until the whites form stiff peaks, being careful not to overdo it (via NPR). The Washington Post explains that the protein in egg whites can only expand so much; if you over-whip them, they won't have the elasticity needed to continue to expand in the oven heat, which causes the soufflé to collapse.

After achieving peak egg white peaks, fold those into the yolk mixture. Since the fatty yolks are heavy and the whites are still delicate, folding in only about 1/3 of the whites to start will help keep the soufflé from crumbling under the weight of the yolks. However, over-mixing remains a concern, so fold until the yolks are lightly incorporated.

Even if you handle the whites flawlessly, soufflés still naturally deflate when they exit the oven. The hot air from the oven gets trapped inside the soufflé, and when it hits room temperature, that air escapes. So gather the crowd around the oven to ooh and ahh at the magic before serving.

Recommended

The Real Reason Soufflé Is So Difficult To Make - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

The Real Reason Soufflé Is So Difficult To Make - Tasting Table? ›

While this sounds simple enough, what you do with the eggs and the precision needed makes the recipe so daunting. Because soufflés get their impressive poof from egg whites, you must separate those from the yolks with absolutely no cross-contamination.

Why are soufflés hard to make? ›

Soufflés can be fussy to make, I guess? You have to separate egg whites from yolks (you don't want any yolks in the egg whites), ensure that you have a nice meringue, and fold in your meringue in parts and not all at once.

What is the trick to a soufflé? ›

Heat matters. Make sure the oven is preheated; that initial hot blast expands the air trapped inside the bubbly foam of batter, which makes it rise. Having the soufflé base hot or warm when you fold in the egg whites helps the temperature rise quickly, too.

Why are soufflés so temperamental? ›

The myth about them falling when there is a loud noise or a slight bump is entirely false. Soufflés will inevitably collapse, not because of being bumped, but because the air that is whipped into the egg whites, which has been heated by the oven, cools, so the soufflé falls.

What can go wrong when making a soufflé? ›

If the temperature is too low, the souffle won't rise properly. If the temperature is too high, the souffle will rise just like a popover with big air pockets inside. Ideally, bake the souffle in the lower third of the oven.

How to make a successful soufflé? ›

Ten tips to keep your souffle high and handsome

Use eggs at room temperature to maximise your rise. Avoid super fresh eggs. Preheat your oven to 200C. A hot oven is crucial to souffle success because it cooks the outside making it hard for the hot air to escape.

What is the secret of the soufflé? ›

There's only one serious secret to the perfect soufflé and that is careful whisking of the egg whites so they keep their volume and puff to a maximum in the oven. The whites should be at room temperature and you can reckon at least one and a half per person.

What deflates a soufflé? ›

While it's cooking, the air trapped in the egg whites expands, causing it to rise. The proteins stiffen a little during baking but when the air cools and starts to escape, there isn't enough 'scaffolding' to hold them up, so they deflate, even when expertly made.

What is the point of soufflé? ›

Every soufflé is an asymmetrical, one-of-a-kind dish. This billowy creation—a hallmark of French culinary tradition—can be served as a sweet dessert with chocolate or berries, or a savory meal with gruyère cheese, vegetables, or meat.

Are soufflés supposed to be gooey? ›

Soufflés are best when they're still slightly runny in the centre. To check if a soufflé is set, gently tap the dish – it should wobble just a little bit. If the centre seems too fluid, cook for a few more minutes.

Why does my soufflé taste eggy? ›

If your Soufflé Cake tastes eggy, it's either undercooked or overcooked. Make sure that you don't increase the temperature, this will also make the eggs rubbery and taste eggy. Stick to a low temperature.

Why is soufflé difficult? ›

“The hardest part of making a soufflé is when you incorporate the beaten egg white with yolks, and the rest of the batter. You have to be very careful to fold the egg whites slowly, so that they don't melt.” “A KitchenAid is the best investment if you want to make soufflés regularly.”

How difficult is it to make a soufflé? ›

Making a successful soufflé is not nearly as difficult as it sounds, but it does require doing a few things properly. They include: Liberally buttering and sugaring your ramekins. This includes the inner base and walls, all the way up to the top rim.

Can sound ruin a soufflé? ›

Of course, most baked goods aren't sensitive enough to respond negatively to regular kitchen noise. If you're baking a particularly fragile cake, like a souffle, you'll be fine if you just close the oven door gently and turn the heavy metal music down a hair.

Why do soufflés have to be served immediately? ›

All soufflés fall within minutes of coming out of the oven because the hot air bubbles contract to shrink and deflate when they hit cooler air. That is why you need to serve them immediately after baking.

What ingredient makes a soufflé rise? ›

A soufflé is made up of a base (usually white sauce or creme patissiere enriched with egg yolks), a flavor (added to the base) and whipped egg whites gently folded in and baked in the oven. While it's cooking, the air trapped in the egg whites expands, causing it to rise.

Are soufflés delicate? ›

While soufflés are delicate and sensitive creations, they're also fundamentally simple, consisting of a flavored base that's lightened with beaten egg whites.

What makes a soufflé special? ›

The custard base provides the flavor and the meringue provides the rising effect that soufflés are famous for. Egg whites, which are pure protein, are beaten to add air to them. The proteins in the egg whites surround the air bubbles and develop into a frothy mixture that, when baked, makes the soufflé rise.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 6088

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.