Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store - Tasting Table (2024)

Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store - Tasting Table (2)

Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store - Tasting Table (3)

Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store

Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store - Tasting Table (4)

Image Source/Getty Images

ByMatthew Spina/

If one item is the platonic ideal of "a pantry staple," it would probably be broth, be itchicken or beef. Broths have so many uses around the kitchen, from pan sauces and soup to wilting greens, that having them on hand at all times is pretty close to essential (via The Spruce Eats). Any home cook would be hard-pressed to go more than a week without using some kind of broth, and even when they aren't essential they can make a great addition in place of water to add extra flavor and depth to a dish.

As much as everyone wants to tell you to make broth and stockyourself, the convenience of being able to crack open a box of broth at a moment's notice is just too much for most cooks to pass up. Bon Appétit will tell you that the benefits of homemade broth, especially in the flavor of soups and stews, are very real. But, even with such clear improvements, it can be hard to justify the hours it takes to produce your own broth, when the reality is most of the time canned or boxed broths and stocks will do the job fine. The one exception to that rule may be beef broth, where the boxed version you get at the grocery can be bad, even by the standard of other premade broth, and for a slightly unexpected reason.

Grocery store beef broth is made with almost no actual beef

Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store - Tasting Table (5)

Ahanov Michael/Shutterstock

Did you know that the federal government regulates how much meat is in your store-bought broth? It's true, but the sad fact is that, according to Serious Eats, beef broth is only required to have one part protein for every 135 parts liquid. That means almost all the flavor in beef stock is coming from other ingredients like yeast extract, so the broth barely tastes like meat, let alone beef. By contrast, regulations say chicken broth must have almost twice as much protein in it. If yourbeef stew turned out less-than-stellar and you are wondering why it was so bland, it's likely because your beef broth didn't even have any real beef in it.

It's not just that beef broths aren't beefy enough, America's Test Kitchen notes that the way most premade beef broths are produced makes them downright bad. Tests of commercial brands, even high-end ones, often had no beef flavor and bitter, burnt notes. Most beef broth bought in a store is produced by large-scale generic distributors, who sell very weak stock to brands, who then use chemists to increase flavor with concentrated or distilled additives. It all adds up to a taste that is a lot more science than beef. Even in dishes that would normally use beef broth, the much superior premade chicken broths end up being a better choice. Sometimes convenience truly comes at a price.

Recommended

Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

Why You Should Reconsider Buying Beef Broth At The Grocery Store - Tasting Table? ›

Tests of commercial brands, even high-end ones, often had no beef flavor and bitter, burnt notes. Most beef broth bought in a store is produced by large-scale generic distributors, who sell very weak stock to brands, who then use chemists to increase flavor with concentrated or distilled additives.

How do you enhance store-bought beef broth? ›

Simmer with fresh herbs.

Bay leaves, thyme, rosemary, sage, lemongrass, and lime leaves are simple upgrades to store-bought stock. Also consider saving herb stems for quickly simmering in soup broth instead of using whole herbs.

Is store-bought beef broth processed? ›

Why Homemade Bone Broth is Healthier than Store-bought. While store-bought stocks and broths aren't always artificial, they are processed and rely on additives and shortcuts to try to mimic the flavor of a homemade stock.

What are the benefits of store-bought bone broth? ›

Bone Broth Benefits

Bone broth contains small amounts of the amino acid glycine, which may promote relaxation and deeper, more restorative sleep. Collagen is the most abundant protein in your body. Its braided, chain-like structure helps it strengthen a variety of tissues, including skin, bones, muscles, and tendons.

Does beef broth have benefits? ›

Both beef and chicken broth are packed with essential nutrients. Beef broth is known for its high protein content, which is essential for muscle growth and repair. It also contains significant amounts of collagen, a protein that supports healthy skin, hair, and joints.

How do you doctor up store bought broth? ›

Woody herbs like rosemary, thyme, oregano, sage, tarragon, and marjoram release tons of flavor as they slowly simmer in stock. Give them a rinse and toss in a big handful of sprigs per quart of store-bought stock.

What makes beef bone broth taste better? ›

A little salt and pepper can go such a long way towards creating a delicious, flavorful broth. Other popular seasonings include herbs like bay leaves, thyme, rosemary, parsley, savory, sage, and basil. Turmeric, cayenne pepper, and ginger can also be added for extra flavor and possibly even some nutritional benefits.

Are store-bought broths healthy? ›

Take note that soups, broths and stocks are notorious for being loaded with sodium so check the labels before purchasing, and look for varieties that are labeled "low sodium" or "unsalted" as you can easily add your salt if needed.

Can store bought beef broth go bad? ›

Store-Bought Beef Broth typically comes in cans or cartons, offering a more consistent flavor. Properly stored in a pantry, unopened broth can last 1-2 years past the expiration date, whereas an opened container should be kept in an airtight container in the fridge and used within 3-4 days.

What is the difference between Swanson beef broth and beef stock? ›

What is the difference between Swanson's cooking stock and broth? Technically speaking, homemade broth is made from meat, bones, and vegetables, while stock is made strictly from bones and vegetables.

What are the pros and cons of bone broth? ›

The pros of bone broth are that it can improve sleep, blood sugar control, skin health and energy levels. On the other hand, the cons are that it: You may not be drinking a real one. This is the number one issue with it.

Is it better to drink bone broth or stock? ›

You'll most likely prefer drinking a broth over a stock.

Your typical stock has more gelatin and nutrients but slightly less flavour than stock. The gelatin is produced via the gentle breakdown of collagen from the bones during a long simmer at low heat.

Is store bought bone broth good for your gut? ›

While it's been claimed that bone broth can help fix or heal gut problems, there is “no robust scientific evidence available yet suggesting that bone broth changes the gut microbiome in any way,” Dr. Shah says. Still, some studies done in rodents have found that bone broth may promote digestive health.

Is too much beef broth bad for you? ›

Also, most bone broths are high in sodium, which can be bad for your heart if you have too much. One serving of broth can provide about 20% of your daily sodium requirement, depending on the recipe.

Is it OK to drink beef broth everyday? ›

Bone broth is generally safe to drink every day if consumed in moderation and as part of a nutritious, omnivorous diet, says Millstine. If you have any food allergies, always check the label.

Why do people drink beef broth? ›

The Bottom Line. Consider incorporating bone broth into your regular routine for its many benefits, including reduced inflammation, improved bone health, better joint support and a healthier gut.

How do you make beef broth taste beefier? ›

To make your beef broth taste even 'beefier', simply add two extra ingredients (ironically, neither of which are beef!). Rub your bones in tomato paste before roasting along with chicken necks. Our favorite ratio is one pack of Chicken Necks to every 10 pounds of beef bones rubbed with 6 oz. paste.

What can I add to beef broth to drink? ›

There are so many ways to go with spices. You can add whole allspice berries, star anise, cloves, and cinnamon sticks to the broth while heating and strain them out before serving.

How do you add depth of flavor to broth? ›

You can extract a clean, strong broth from a combination of water and several pantry ingredients. It's all about layering powerful flavor-enhancers that you probably already have on hand—bacon, tomato paste, herbs, peppercorns, a Parmesan rind, and, of course, kosher salt.

How do you thicken store bought beef stock? ›

So, when you're not up for brewing a whole potful of gelatin-rich broth, you can simply bloom some powdered gelatin in boxed or canned stock—about one and a half teaspoons per cup of stock will do the trick.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 5652

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.