Why You Shouldn't Discredit Old Cookbooks - Tasting Table (2024)

Why You Shouldn't Discredit Old Cookbooks - Tasting Table (4)

Elena Efimova - Shutterstock

ByErin Shaw/

With the advent of the internet and information suddenly at everyone's fingertips, the days of perusing cookbooks to come up with recipes for dinner seems to have passed us by. Nowadays, while there are many glossy cookbooks for sale in local bookstores, there are also websites, podcasts, YouTube channels, and even TikTok accounts devoted to food tips and recipes. The information is not only readily available, but in your face all day long. (Do you even know where your old copy of "Joy of Cooking" is?)

While there is nothing wrong with reading food blogs, or other publications (you're reading one now, after all), there's something to be said for valuing our older physical copies of cookbooks, especially those written during the earlier part of the 20th century. If you have good cookbooks, hold on to them. And if you don't, you might want to take a peak next time you walk past a yard sale or used bookstore.

Here's why.

Older cookbooks tend to cover the basics

Why You Shouldn't Discredit Old Cookbooks - Tasting Table (5)

Uryupina Nadezhda - Shutterstock

When looking at vintage cookbooks from the early part of the 20th century, you are sure to find some seemingly odd recipes that might make your head turn. Many old cook books were teaching home cooks how to feed a family during the depression or with WWII rations and during those times, it was more important to put food into bellies than to stress about hyper-nutrient recipes. Country Living notes that 1924's "Modern Priscilla Cook Book"is full of sugar-heavy recipes. In fact, if you search the word "sugar" in the archived text, there are over 1,000 results.

While vintage cookbooks may not always take health and wellness into consideration, Backdoor Survival notes that vintage cookbooks are a great way to learn how to cook from scratch. Need to learn how to boil eggs or cook rice? An older cookbook has your back. Don't have saffron in your pantry, or access to organic short ribs? No problem! You can still cook something tasty from an old cookbook.

In addition, many cookbooks from the 1940s and 1950s came along before people used fancy kitchen appliances like stand mixers, air fryers, and sous vide machines, Serious Eats explains.

There's history there

Why You Shouldn't Discredit Old Cookbooks - Tasting Table (6)

4 PM production - Shutterstock

Older cookbooks are also a really fun way to learn about what was happening in the world around the time they were written. Many old cookbooks will have introductions or preambles that will tell you about the time they were written in, or give you context clues about that time in history.Making a meal from an old cookbook is sort of like equal parts cooking lesson and history lesson. So if you're a history nerd, this can be a fun experiment. Older cookbook recipes are also really fun for throwback theme parties with friends.

Vintage cookbook recipes can even tap into your own family history. Food52 notes that old cookbooks are a way to connect to self and to family history. Old recipes are like historical markers in life. Is there a cookie recipe you always made with your mom at holiday times? Is her handwriting in the margin of the pages? Did grandpa love a particular pie recipe at Thanksgiving? Does a certain chicken casserole remind you of your dad?

Holding onto those older cookbooks is a great way to pass on family traditions and to remember family history.So before you go donating all your old cookbooks, consider holding onto a few classics.

Recommended

Why You Shouldn't Discredit Old Cookbooks - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

Is there any value in old cook books? ›

Investment value: Old cookbooks are sometimes collected as a "financial investment," Sawyer said. The value of a cookbook can go up over time, especially if it's considered rare, has historical significance and is in good condition.

Should I get rid of old cookbooks? ›

As much as we all love cookbooks, sometimes you hit a point where you just have to let a few go. But unless a cookbook is totally trashed or something flimsy you put together in grade school, you don't really want to just throw them in the garbage. Someone else could get use out of them!

How to review a cookbook? ›

Cookbook reviews mostly focus on how the recipes turn out — how tasty the dishes are, or how authentic they are. Sometimes they'll also talk about the quality of writing, or how much you learn about some region's culinary history or food science or the author's childhood or whatever.

Why are cookbooks important? ›

Recipes are passed down from generation to generation, and a lot of heart and soul goes into curating them. Cookbooks allow us to dive into those traditions and the culture while educating its readers about the importance and joy of cooking.

Are any old books worth anything? ›

Condition is very important and will greatly influence value. A beaten-up old book that is falling apart will have little value. First editions are sought-after by book collectors and a first edition is usually more valuable than a later printing. A first edition signed by the author will have even greater value.

Where is the best place to sell old cookbooks? ›

Sell Individual Cookbooks on eBay or Amazon

this route will get you the most money for your collection. We recommend eBay vs Amazon if you don't want to be selling for over a month. If you have a lot of time, Amazon works well for books and draws the largest audience.

Does anyone still buy cookbooks? ›

But do cookbooks still sell? Yes, they do. In fact, it's a burgeoning and competitive market. But that's just another reason to make sure that you do everything possible to make your cookbook the best it can be.

Are cookbooks worth keeping? ›

A cookbook might teach you how to diagnose and correct your technique. Take, for example, the cookbook “Salt Fat Acid Heat,” which breaks down cooking into the basic elements. Once you understand the way certain elements work together, you can walk away a better cook. Using cookbooks can also simply be a delight.

Does anyone collect old cookbooks? ›

Many collectors are drawn to these older books because they catered for kitchens before electricity, microwaves, and refrigerators. Their recipes reflect dishes, ingredients and styles of cooking that have been forgotten.

What are the 7 questions of a cookbook reviewer? ›

Here's my questions–who knows, maybe they'll help you the next time you're having brain freeze in the Cookbooks section.
  • Question 1: Is it useful? ...
  • Question 2: Is it thoughtful? ...
  • Question 3: Is it new? ...
  • Question 4: Does it tell a story? ...
  • Question 5: Is it well-designed? ...
  • Question 6: Is it focused?
Nov 14, 2011

How do you analyze a cookbook? ›

Themes to consider
  1. Why is the author writing this book?
  2. Who is the intended audience? ...
  3. What kind of assumptions does the author(s) make about cooking/cuisine/food?
  4. What kinds of ingredients are used? ...
  5. How precise are the recipes?

Are old cookbooks better? ›

Older cookbooks tend to cover the basics

In fact, if you search the word "sugar" in the archived text, there are over 1,000 results. While vintage cookbooks may not always take health and wellness into consideration, Backdoor Survival notes that vintage cookbooks are a great way to learn how to cook from scratch.

Do people use cookbooks anymore? ›

Always a popular category, cookbook sales have soared in the past three years. In 2021, cookbook sales were 42% higher than they were the year before. Since then, the upward trend has remained steady. Cookbook sales have not slowed down.

What to do with cookbooks you don t want? ›

Donate Cookbooks to Passionate Home cooks!

Make sure your cookbooks are in good condition before donating them — it's simply good manners. And if you don't find where to donate your cookbooks, offer them for free on your social media or with a classified ad in the newspaper.

How do I know if my books are valuable? ›

Assessing book values at a glance:
  • Look for other copies of the book for sale online.
  • Take a close look at the condition of the book.
  • Remember that old does not necessarily mean valuable.
  • Determine if the book is signed or a notable edition.
  • Check out this blog post on book pricing for resale.
Jan 19, 2024

How to sell old cookery books? ›

The Best Way to Sell Cookbooks Online

Run an Ecwid store on your own website, on popular social media platforms, or through marketplaces like Amazon or eBay. Open your very own Instant Site in just a few minutes or simply add a “Buy Now” button to your blog.

Is there a market for cookbooks? ›

Cookbooks sell extraordinarily well. According to Kristen Mclean of the NPD market research group, close to 20 million cookbooks fly off the shelves every year in the US alone. Not only that, but it's one of the most stable book markets with only tiny annual fluctuations.

How old do books have to be to be valuable? ›

Age and Imprint

Any book published before 1900, especially on Americana, is potentially valuable. On the other hand, there are many rare books that are not more than 20 years old. Usually, these books are in demand and rare because of the combined factors of importance and scarcity.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Virgilio Hermann JD

Last Updated:

Views: 6148

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Virgilio Hermann JD

Birthday: 1997-12-21

Address: 6946 Schoen Cove, Sipesshire, MO 55944

Phone: +3763365785260

Job: Accounting Engineer

Hobby: Web surfing, Rafting, Dowsing, Stand-up comedy, Ghost hunting, Swimming, Amateur radio

Introduction: My name is Virgilio Hermann JD, I am a fine, gifted, beautiful, encouraging, kind, talented, zealous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.